Scale mail vs leather armor

The age-old debate: scale mail vs leather armor! Both have their own unique advantages and disadvantages, which I'll outline below.

Scale Mail:

Pros:

  1. Protection: Scale mail provides excellent protection against slashing and piercing attacks, thanks to its overlapping scales that absorb and distribute impact.
  2. Durability: Scale mail is generally more durable than leather armor, as the scales are less prone to tearing or puncturing.
  3. Flexibility: Scale mail allows for greater flexibility and mobility, as the scales can move independently to accommodate the wearer's movements.

Cons:

  1. Weight: Scale mail can be quite heavy, which can affect the wearer's mobility and endurance.
  2. Cost: Scale mail is often more expensive to produce and maintain than leather armor.
  3. Noise: The rattling of the scales can be noisy, which may alert enemies to the wearer's presence.

Leather Armor:

Pros:

  1. Lightweight: Leather armor is generally lighter and more comfortable to wear, making it ideal for long periods of wear or for those who prioritize mobility.
  2. Affordability: Leather armor is often less expensive to produce and maintain than scale mail.
  3. Silent: Leather armor is quieter than scale mail, making it a better choice for stealthy or covert operations.

Cons:

  1. Protection: Leather armor provides less protection against slashing and piercing attacks, as it can tear or puncture more easily.
  2. Durability: Leather armor is more prone to wear and tear, requiring more frequent maintenance and replacement.
  3. Limited flexibility: Leather armor can be less flexible than scale mail, restricting the wearer's movements.

Ultimate Verdict:

Scale mail is generally better suited for:

Leather armor is better suited for:

Of course, the choice ultimately depends on the specific needs and preferences of the wearer.